Sunday, 17 March 2024

Navigating Turmoil in Small and Mid Cap Funds: An Informed Approach

Prudent Small Cap Play: Safeguarding Investments, Mitigating Liquidity Woes

—------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Download this small cap informed approach blog as pdf and share in your social media groups.

—-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Introduction

The mutual fund industry has been rocked by recent concerns raised by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) regarding the liquidity and risk management practices of small and mid-cap funds. This has created a wave of uncertainty among investors, highlighting the need for a well-informed approach to navigating the current turmoil.

2. Understanding the Noise

SEBI's warnings have focused on the potential risks associated with small and mid-cap funds, particularly their ability to manage liquidity and redemptions effectively. These concerns have sparked discussions and raised questions about the suitability of these funds for individual investment portfolios.

3. The Concept of Stress Tests

To address these issues, SEBI has proposed conducting stress tests for small and mid-cap funds. These tests aim to assess a fund's capacity to withstand adverse market conditions by evaluating its ability to manage liquidity, handle redemptions, and mitigate asset-liability mismatches.

4. Calculating Stress Test Values

Stress test values are calculated by simulating extreme market scenarios and assessing the potential impact on a fund's performance. These tests consider various factors, including liquidity of the underlying assets, redemption patterns, asset-liability mismatches, market conditions, free float market capitalization, and portfolio turnover.

5. Latest Stress Test Values for Top 10 Small Cap Funds

The following table presents the latest stress test values for the top 10 small cap funds, along with their 3-year annualized returns, days required to liquidate 50% of the portfolio, and assets under management (AUM):


SNO

Small cap Fund

3-Year Annualised Return

Stress Test: Days to Liquidate 50% Portfolio

Assets Under Management (AUM) in ₹ crores

1

SBI

21%

60

25,525

2

HDFC

26%

42

28,599

3

Nippon India

30%

27

46,044

4

Quant

36%

22

17,232

5

HSBC

26%

15

13,743

6. Understanding Stress Test Values

The stress test values in the table provide insights into the risk and liquidity profiles of these funds. A higher stress test value indicates that it may take longer for the fund to liquidate a significant portion of its portfolio, potentially impacting an investor's ability to redeem their investments during periods of market stress or increased redemption requests.


The relationship between a fund's AUM, portfolio composition, and liquidity estimates is crucial. Funds with larger AUMs and a higher concentration of illiquid or small-cap stocks may face greater challenges in liquidating their positions quickly, leading to higher stress test values.

7. Market Downturn: A Bitter Pill for Investors

The recent market downturn has served as a harsh reminder of the volatility associated with small and mid-cap funds. Many investors have experienced significant losses in their portfolios, underscoring the importance of maintaining a long-term perspective and avoiding knee-jerk reactions to short-term market fluctuations.

8. Herd Mentality: A Pitfall to Avoid

One of the most significant pitfalls for investors is the tendency to follow the herd mentality, making decisions based on market noise and collective sentiment rather than sound analysis and individual financial goals. It is crucial for investors to resist this temptation and make informed choices based on their risk tolerance, investment horizon, and overall financial objectives. Read more here about Herd mentality in Tamil - click here. You can read more about biases in investments in Tamil, here

9. SIP vs. Lump Sum: Which Approach Is Better?

In volatile markets, Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) can offer a more prudent approach compared to lump-sum investments. SIPs allow investors to gradually accumulate units over time, potentially benefiting from rupee-cost averaging and minimising the impact of market volatility. For a comprehensive guide on SIPs, refer to [Link to Tamil SIP guide].

10. Understanding Long-Term Returns and Market Movements

While short-term market fluctuations can be unnerving, it is essential for investors to maintain a long-term perspective. Historical data has consistently demonstrated that equity markets tend to recover from downturns and deliver attractive returns over extended periods. To gain a deeper understanding of long-term market trends and their implications, explore [Link to long-term market trends resource].

11. Lessons from the Past: Liquidity Concerns and Redemption Challenges

The mutual fund industry has witnessed instances where fund houses faced difficulties in honouring redemption requests due to low liquidity levels in their portfolios. These events serve as a stark reminder of the importance of considering a fund's size, liquidity profile, and redemption patterns when making investment decisions.

12. Election Year Uncertainty: A Case for Caution

With elections on the horizon, investors should exercise caution when allocating funds to riskier assets, such as small and mid-cap funds. Election periods often bring heightened uncertainty and market volatility, which can amplify the risks associated with these funds.

13. Conclusion

Navigating the turmoil in small and mid-cap funds requires a well-informed and disciplined approach. By understanding the concept of stress tests, considering long-term returns, avoiding herd mentality, and exercising caution during periods of uncertainty, investors can make better-informed decisions about their investments.

14. Call to action

In light of the recent turmoil in small and mid-cap funds, consider starting a systematic investment plan (SIP) in a diversified equity fund as a prudent investment approach. Alternatively, reach out to us for a comprehensive review of your existing investments. We can guide you through these volatile times, fine-tune your portfolio alignment with your goals, and ensure your hard-earned money is optimally invested for long-term growth. Take the first step towards fortifying your financial future by reach out to us today.

15. Further reading

For those seeking comprehensive guidance on mutual fund investing, explore [Link to our Tamil mutual fund book].


This is time of tax saving season, read more about tax saving ELSS here


Tags: #Small-cap funds, #mid-cap funds, #mutual funds, #stress tests, #liquidity, #risk management, #long-term investing, #investor education.